Skip to content

Positive vision has to be an elected assembly – local authorities can’t deliver on their own

January 20, 2014

Diana Johnson MP’s column in today’s Yorkshire Post (below) is strong on analysis and adds favourably to the debate on Yorkshire’s future. However, the solution of more power to the cities fails on two counts. Firstly, what happens to the rural areas? Are they lumped together with the nearby city (expect an outcry from the leafy parts of the East Riding if they are to be subsumed by Hull!). Secondly, we know that many local authorities are just not up to it. Essentially they are lacking in the resources to implement the changes Diana Johnson suggests. No, the best solution for ‘neglected Yorkshire’ remains an elected assembly. It would be for the whole of Yorkshire (urban and rural alike) and it would have the critical mass (as has been the case in Wales and Scotland) to really make a difference .

Diana Johnson: Positive vision needed for the neglected North

MANY northern citizens were told to pack their bags last October and move elsewhere for work. This latest call came in The Economist, who asserted that “governments should not try to rescue failing towns” such as Hull, Middlesbrough, Burnley and Hartlepool. Ambitious residents should migrate to more prosperous places.

As reprehensible as this argument is, it expresses one undeniable truth: despite some recovery nationally, after three needless years of flat-lining, swathes of the North remains in recession. All the cities mentioned have unemployment above the national average – higher now than in March 2010.

Private sector employment rose by 1.4 per cent in the South East in the second quarter of 2013, but only rose by 0.1 per cent in the rest of England. It declined by 0.6 per cent in the north west. Britain needs a balanced recovery across all regions. Halving the output gap between the North and the national average would increase Britain’s output by £41bn – not an insignificant contribution to deficit reduction.

I see the economic damage in Hull. With thousands of private and public sector jobs gone, we have more people not in education, employment or training – so called “neets” – busy food banks and loan sharks occupying empty shops.

Britain wasn’t always like this. Northern manufacturing powered Britain through the Industrial Revolution. By the 1970s, London had declined and for a time was poorer than the rest of the country, with the closing of east London’s docks a classic example.

Rather than pursuing free market neglect and abandonment, Michael Heseltine started 30 years of London Docklands regeneration in 1980, primed by massive and continuing public and private investment.

Hull, facing similar decline in traditional marine industries, wasn’t so blessed.

Contrary to The Economist’s remarks about northern towns being “propped up on piles of public money”, Greater London has had a fatter slice of public investment and more political weight put behind attracting private investment than the north.

Even without northern migrants, London and the South East are already overcrowded, with unaffordable housing and a creaking transport network. A southern recovery based on financial services, private consumer debt and a new property bubble will not last.

We currently have the bizarre situation where those caught out by the lack of affordable housing and benefit cuts in the South East are encouraged to move north for cheaper housing, while those in the north struggling with the lack of jobs are told to move south for work.

We need only look to the Continent to find a positive alternative vision for our northern cities. Dresden, for example – formerly the eastern “sick man” of a reunified Germany – grew faster than most other European cities in the early-2000s by creating a bustling technological sector: “silicon Saxony”. Although the remedies are as diverse as the cities themselves, one common thread runs through all the success stories: giving local authorities the power and money to pioneer local solutions for local circumstances

Labour should delegate more powers to local authorities, particularly in employment and training. Labour councils such as Newham have worked with businesses and the unemployed to match workers to jobs, boosting local job acceptances from two per cent to 80 per cent. By opting schools out of council control en masse, the coalition’s education policy undermines the successes of councils like Camden in bringing educators and employers together.

Newcastle’s alternative co-operative schools model could trigger a skills revolution.

Giving local schools and universities places in local enterprise partnerships, and businesspeople positions in school governors’ boards, is also essential.

Finally, we should enhance councils’ borrowing powers further and back calls for a regional investment bank, possibly financed through a one-off levy on commercial banks.

However, devolving power – not just blame – is only effective in regenerating cities like Hull if coupled with a strong central government commitment to reducing regional inequalities. The coalition has used the rhetoric of decentralisation and “rebalancing the economy” as a smokescreen for cuts to the north.

In the cities The Economist mentioned, local authority spending cuts range from £184 to £268 per head between 2010 and 2015 – well above the national average of £125.

In 1997 Labour started to rekindle growth in northern cities. We must continue where we left off. Free market neglect has been tried in the North.

We now need “one nation” regeneration.

*Diana Johnson is Labour MP for Hull North. This article was first published in the Fabian Review


From → Uncategorized

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: